Edgar Henry Smith

Leading Seaman Edgar Henry Smith – Lost with the S.V. Trebiskin

The Trebiskin and the Great Storm of 1908

Edgar Henry Smith
credit - 
Photo courtesy of nephew Ross Vivian
The S.V. Trebiskin, a ketch registered at the port of Padstow, Cornwall, first made the news during the Great Storm of 1908. She became stranded on the Cardiff Grounds, prompting the launch of the Barry lifeboat. Fortunately, a shift in the wind allowed her three-man crew to refloat the vessel and escape disaster.

The Trebiskin’s Wartime Role

By the time of the First World War, small sailing vessels like the Trebiskin still played a crucial role in the coastal coal trade. Although steamships dominated long-distance and military transport, hundreds of sailing ketches carried cargoes of coal from South Wales ports such as Swansea across the Bristol Channel and Irish Sea. These ships supplied fuel to towns, industries, and naval facilities that depended on coal for power.

The Trebiskin, though modest in size, was part of this vital wartime network. Sail-powered coal carriers were slower and more vulnerable than steamships, but they were often used to free up larger vessels for overseas trade and troop convoys. Crews of such ships faced enormous risks: shifting cargoes in rough seas, sudden gales, and, during the war, the ever-present threat of German U-boats and mines.

Loss of the Trebiskin in 1918

On 4th November 1918, the Trebiskin was last sighted sailing near the Mixon Sandbank, off the South Wales coast. Three days later, on the 7th, wreckage identified as belonging to the ketch was found on the Mixon. None of her crew survived.

One of those lost was Leading Seaman Edgar Henry Smith.

Early Life and Naval Career

Edgar Henry Smith 
Royal Navy Records
Edgar was born on 18th June 1894 in the small outport of Island Cove, Newfoundland, the son of Simeon and Maria (Whalen) Smith.

On 18th March 1914, he passed his medical examination and was recommended for enlistment with the Royal Naval Reserve, where he completed his basic naval training on board HMS Calypso.

When war was declared in August 1914, Edgar was called up by Royal Proclamation. Reporting to St. John’s on 13th August, he embarked on the S.S. Carthaginian for England, arriving at HMS Vivid, the Royal Navy’s training establishment at Devonport.

Over the next four years, Edgar served at a range of naval facilities and on several warships. He was assigned to HMS Prince George, a pre-dreadnought battleship, during the Gallipoli Campaign of 1915. He took part in both the landings and the evacuation and was mentioned in dispatches by the Vice-Admiral commanding the Eastern Mediterranean Squadron for “good services during these operations.”

Orders to the Trebiskin

On 26th August 1918, Edgar received new orders to report to HMS President III, the navy’s accounting base for personnel assigned to merchant vessels. He was then detailed to serve as a gunner aboard the Trebiskin, which was sailing with a crew of five.

The ketch departed Swansea on 4th November, bound for Youghal, Ireland, with a cargo of coal. Somewhere in the heavy seas off the Mixon Sandbank, she was lost. At the subsequent Swansea inquest, the jury could not determine the exact cause but concluded that the Trebiskin may have foundered under the weight of her cargo in rough conditions.

The Crew

Among those lost were Leading Seaman Edgar Henry Smith and Seaman John Doyle, both from Newfoundland, along with three other crew members. John Doyle’s body was never recovered.

Burial at Danygraig Cemetery

South Wales Daily Post
On 14th December 1918, the South Wales Daily Post reported that Edgar’s body had been washed ashore on the Swansea foreshore. He was formally identified, and the cause of death was recorded as “Found Drowned.” His official date of death was registered as 12th November 1918.

Edgar Henry Smith
Danygraig Cemetery
credit - findagrave
Edgar was laid to rest at Danygraig Cemetery, Swansea. His grave today marks the sacrifice of a Newfoundland seaman whose war service spanned from Gallipoli to the coal trade routes of the Bristol Channel.

Western Mail









Western Mail






Further reports in the Western Mail later that December confirmed that two more bodies from the Trebiskin had also been recovered, underlining the full extent of the tragedy.

Legacy

Edgar was a long way from home when his body was washed ashore at Swansea. A young man from a small Newfoundland outport, he ended his days on the South Wales coast — a reminder of how the First World War drew men from across the globe into common service and sacrifice.

At Danygraig Cemetery, his grave stands among those of other foreign servicemen who never returned home — Australians, Canadians, and Newfoundlanders who died while serving in Britain. Together, their memorials speak to Swansea’s unexpected role as a resting place for men of many nations, all bound by the shared ordeal of war.

Comments

Popular Posts